DebbieRobinson.com.au

Home
Essays
The Italians  (View Essay)

In view of international standards, the exhibition Titian to Tiepolo: Three Centuries of Italian Art held by the National Gallery of Australia in 2002 attracted attendance figures well below the 250,000 visitors required as an entry mark to “Blockbuster” status.1 It cannot be refuted however, that The Italians was conceived as a “Blockbuster”. Whilst the majority of artists on display would not be known to the general public the inclusion of works by the great names of Italian art as Leonardo, Michelangelo and Raphael shows an attempt to popularize by appealing to those attendees desirous of seeing Masterpieces of incalculable value. This essay will argue that the integrity of The Italians exhibition and associated scholarship was critically compromised from its conception as it was more of a financial exercise in timely profit making as opposed to a considered curatorial endeavour.

Moma Thematic  (View Essay)

In 2001, the Tate’s international collection of modern and contemporary art moved to its specifically redesigned site at Bankside in South London. The move provided the opportunity to ‘clean house’ so to speak and remove the old ‘isms’ associated with the chronological historical display thus rearranging the institution for the new millennium. Similarly, in New York, with the majority of its collection destined for storage during rebuilding, the Museum of Modern Art was also “rethink(ing) the institution from top to bottom”.1 In rethinking the institution, MoMA and Tate Modern were not thinking solely of the collection. The institution is more than just the collection it is rather the public perception of that collection. Thus, the directors of MoMA and Tate Modern were looking not only to reinvigorate the collection but also to reinvigorate the way in which the public responded to that collection.

Tassi Attribution  (View Essay)

A River Landscape with Shepherds and Boating Scene is an idyllic representation of country life. The influence of Northern artists can be seen in the use of cool, silvery tones and the low placement of the horizon which emphasises the large expanse of sky. The attribution for this painting has been given to Agostino Tassi (1578-1644) and indeed, it contains many motifs which have found a basis in his work. For example the Shepherd herding sheep over a hill (Fig. 1), boating parties in a river landscape (Fig. 3), the bare branch and hanging ivy motifs, and the prominence of birds and architecture. A thorough examination of details, however, will reveal that whilst the inspiration for these motifs may have derived from Tassi’s work, their method of formation, stylistically and technically, is not conducive with an attribution to Tassi but rather with an attribution to Filippo Napoletano.

Gestures of Despair  (View Essay)

Throughout the medieval period, images of the crucifixion have undergone a considerable transformation in their depiction of grief with particular emphasis on those gestures displayed by Mary and John. From its earliest incarnation in the Rabbula Gospels of A.D. 586 to its most emotive point in the frescoes of Duccio in the fourteenth century we see an evolution from an emphasis on Divinity and the Christ Triumphant to an emphasis on humanity and the Christ Patiens.

Rosa Attribution  (View Essay)

“The association of beauty and horror was frequent in what were accounted sublime scenes; and it was Salvator [Rosa] who helped to establish this conjunction.”1 A Shipwreck on the Coast presents the epitome of the sublime in combining the horrific theme of the shipwreck with the wild beauty of the coastal landscape. An attribution for this painting has been given to Salvator Rosa (1615-1673) as it features many of the motifs which were identified with his oeuvre. Most notably the craggy precipices, the splintered trees and wind swept bluffs.

Quest for Arcadia  (View Catalogue)

Ruins represent the primary element in both the myth and actuality of Arcadia. The true Arcadia, situated in the mountainous Pelopennese region of Greece, holds the ancient ruins of the city of Mycenae. The poet Alpheius wrote of Mycenae in the second century “This birthplace of heroes was now scarcely above ground… So, as I passed thee by, did I see thee, unhappy Mycanae, more waste than any goat-fold. The goat herds pointed thee out and ….said, ‘Here stood the city rich in gold, the city that the Cyclops built.’” For Alpheius, the ruins of Mycenae stand not only as a document of a civilisation lost, but moreover they embody a sense of the narrative of both Gods and mortals. They evoke an emotive nostalgia for an archaic meaning forever lost. Thus Alpheius sets the tradition for the poetics of ruins.